1191fdedc0993f514bfa2f2d4ca57c40d930ce3e
1 Commits
| Author | SHA1 | Message | Date | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 cognitive
|
25c6794cd5 |
fix(agent): compaction honors session thinking level and silent-clamps unsupported-effort models
Triple-stacked failure on the same axis (thinking effort) produced the
user-visible
Error: Compaction failed: Thinking effort high is not supported by
xai-oauth/grok-build.
Supported efforts:
(empty list after the colon) whenever the active model was a curated
xAI catalog entry with compat.supportsReasoningEffort: false.
Three defects lined up. (1) Behavior: compaction at four call sites
in packages/agent/src/compaction/compaction.ts hardcoded
reasoning: Effort.High and never threaded session.thinkingLevel —
the user's /model :off selection (and any explicit low/medium) was
silently overridden. On every other model this was invisible.
(2) Validation: requireSupportedEffort threw at the openai-flavored
mapper layer before the wire-side omitReasoningEffort gate in
providers/xai-responses.ts ever ran; two contradictory guards on the
same wire param. (3) Message: when getSupportedEfforts returned [],
the rendered error tail was 'Supported efforts: ' with nothing after
the colon — disappears as a side-effect of fix #2.
Fix #1 — thread ThinkingLevel | undefined end-to-end. Add
SummaryOptions.thinkingLevel and HandoffOptions.thinkingLevel.
Convert via a single exhaustive switch (effortFromThinkingLevel) in
the new resolveCompactionEffort helper:
- Off → undefined (omit reasoning entirely)
- undefined/Inherit → Effort.High → clamp per model (preserves the
historical default for users
who never touched the dial)
- explicit Effort → respect user → clamp per model
resolveCompactionEffort lives in compaction.ts; all four call sites
(generateSummary, generateHandoff, generateShortSummary,
generateTurnPrefixSummary) route through it. agent-session.ts threads
this.thinkingLevel into all three production compaction entry points
(manual /compact at L6201, auto-compaction at L6458 — the most-fired
path, originally missed in plan review — and direct generateHandoff
at L5465). The audit-gate test
(test/agent-session-compaction-thinking-threading.test.ts) scans the
file with a brace-balanced extractor and refuses any unthreaded site.
Fix #2 — silent-clamp at the openai-flavored mapper layer. Extract
exported modelOmitsReasoningEffort(model) in model-thinking.ts as the
single source of truth for compat.supportsReasoningEffort: false on
openai-responses* APIs. getSupportedEfforts now calls it instead of
inlining the check (pure refactor — observable behavior preserved).
resolveOpenAiReasoningEffort in stream.ts early-returns undefined
when the predicate is true, so the wire-side omitReasoningEffort
gate (providers/xai-responses.ts:78) becomes the single source of
truth for the actual strip — no redundant throw.
Three regression tests pin the contract:
- packages/ai/test/xai-oauth-effort-strip.test.ts (5 tests):
modelOmitsReasoningEffort returns true for grok-build and
grok-4.20-0309-reasoning, false for grok-4.3 / Anthropic /
openai-completions.
- packages/agent/test/compaction-thinking-level.test.ts (5 tests):
every ThinkingLevel outcome through generateHandoff — Off stays
undefined (not coerced to High), Low stays Low, Inherit / undefined
default to High, grok-build clamps to undefined regardless of
requested level. Covers the Codex-caught Off-vs-not-provided
distinction.
- packages/coding-agent/test/agent-session-compaction-thinking-threading.test.ts
(2 tests): brace-balanced source scan asserts every direct
compact() / generateHandoff() in agent-session.ts threads
'thinkingLevel: this.thinkingLevel'; floor of 3 threaded sites.
TDD red-green verified for fix #1: temporarily reverted the handoff
call-site back to hardcoded Effort.High → compaction-thinking-level
went 2 pass / 3 fail (Off coerced, Low overridden, grok-build throws);
restored → 5 pass / 0 fail.
Verified:
- packages/agent: 127 pass / 0 fail
- packages/ai: 1061 pass / 337 skip / 0 fail
- packages/coding-agent (focused): 179 pass / 5 skip / 0 fail
- biome + tsgo --noEmit clean across all three packages
Out of scope (follow-ups):
- branch-summarization.ts:307 already passes no reasoning — no edit.
- The empty-list error message at model-thinking.ts:296 is now
structurally unreachable from the openai-responses path.
- modelOmitsReasoningEffort and grokSupportsReasoningEffort
(xai-responses.ts:22) overlap; collapse into a single predicate
in a future commit.
Op: correct
Restores: spec:compaction-honors-session-thinking-level
Restores: spec:xai-oauth-grok-build-compaction-no-throw
(cherry picked from commit e07b47ee46769053c658819437e2478389a4cee0)
|